Getting paid on a public job: the clock is in your contract, not in the Town's mood

Here is a situation most contractors who work for towns, villages and school districts will recognize. The pay application went in. The engineer recommended it. The board even voted on it. And then nothing. Weeks go by, the phone calls get vaguer, and somebody at the office starts talking about a "process."

We just spent a couple of days reading one of these contracts cover to cover, all 645 pages of it, for a water main job. What we found is the point of this article: almost everything the owner was leaning on was either not in the contract or was contradicted by it. The contractor had more rights than anyone at the table was aware of, including the contractor.

This is not legal advice and your contract is not our contract. But the pattern is common enough to be worth walking through.

1. Find the real payment clock. It is probably shorter than you think.

Most public jobs in New York run on the EJCDC general conditions. The base document says payment is due a certain number of days after the engineer presents the application to the owner. Then the supplementary conditions, which almost nobody reads, amend that paragraph. On the job we read, the base conditions said ten days and the supplement replaced it with twenty. Elsewhere it can go the other way.

Here is why that matters. The owner's office will usually quote you a number out of state law: thirty days, or forty-five if an elected board has to approve payments. Those are the outer limits the law puts on how slow a public owner is allowed to be. They are not permission to ignore the shorter number the owner agreed to in writing. If your contract says twenty, twenty is when it is due. Read the supplementary conditions first, then the general conditions, and know which document the owner is quoting at you.

2. "We haven't found it acceptable yet" is not a thing.

The clause everyone reaches for says payment becomes due "if the Owner finds the application acceptable." Read alone, that sounds like an open-ended veto. It is not, because the same contract spells out the only way an owner can decline to pay a recommended amount: a set-off, and a set-off has rules.

Under the standard conditions the owner has to give you immediate written notice, with a copy to the engineer, that states the reasons and states the specific dollar amount being withheld, and then promptly pay the rest. A phone call is not a set-off. Silence is not a set-off. A partial payment with no explanation is not a set-off. And if the board already voted to approve the application, the "acceptable" question is answered. There is nothing left to wait on.

Most informal delays end the moment you ask for the set-off in writing, because nobody wants to sign their name under a reason that will not hold up.

3. The interest is automatic, and almost nobody invoices it.

On New York public work, late payment carries interest by statute, and on the job we read the contract itself said so in one sentence. The rate is tied to the state tax department's overpayment rate, which is published every quarter. It is not a windfall. At six percent, a hundred thousand dollars held late costs the owner about sixteen dollars a day.

What makes it useful is not the money. It is that the statute says the owner "shall" pay it, with no requirement that you ask first, and a municipality has to explain an interest line at a public meeting. Put the number on the invoice. Say where it comes from. Watch how quickly the conversation changes.

4. Close your own gaps before you push.

Before you send anything sharp, check the conditions the owner could legitimately use against you, because an engineer looking for a defensible reason to sit on a pay app will find one if you leave it there. The usual ones:

• Were your schedules formally accepted? Progress schedule, schedule of submittals, schedule of values. The standard conditions say no progress payment is due until the engineer has accepted them. If you never got that acceptance in writing, get it now.
• Did every application after the first carry the affidavit? The one that says prior payments were applied to prior obligations. It is a line most people skip.
• Is the application on the form the contract requires, with the number of copies it requires, with the updated schedule attached? Petty, but it is a legitimate reason to bounce it.

Fix those quietly. Then you are pushing from clean ground.

5. Notice only counts if it is given the way the contract says.

Every one of these contracts has a paragraph on how written notice has to be delivered. Usually it is certified mail, hand delivery, or email with the words "Formal Notice" in the subject line. A conversation with the supervisor at the Monday board meeting is not notice, and six months from now it will not exist. From the day a payment goes late, every communication about it goes certified or with that subject line. Nothing else.

6. Build the one-page ledger. It wins more arguments than any letter.

For each application: the date it went to the engineer, the date the engineer recommended it or sent it back and why, the date it was presented to the owner, the amount recommended, the amount paid, the date paid, the days late, and the interest. One page. Dated. Boring.

Hand that to a town attorney and the "process" conversation is over, because every date on it came out of their own files. It is the single most persuasive document in a payment dispute, and it takes an afternoon to build.

What the contract gives you after that

The standard conditions have an escalation ladder that does not require suing anyone: a written request for evidence that the owner has the money (yes, that is a clause), the set-off demand above, a formal claim with its own deadlines, and after thirty days of non-payment of an amount finally determined to be due, a seven-day notice that lets you stop work or terminate. The last one is a heavy tool and you do not use it without a lawyer. But it exists, and knowing it exists changes how the meeting goes.

None of this is clever. It is just reading the contract you signed, all of it, before the other side assumes you have not.

Sitting on a late pay app? Tell us about it →